Get The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian PDF

By Alan Brudner

ISBN-10: 0520085965

ISBN-13: 9780520085961

Countering the influential view of serious felony reports that legislation is an incoherent mix of conflicting political ideologies, this e-book forges a new paradigm for figuring out the typical legislations as being unified and systematic. Alan Brudner applies Hegel's criminal and ethical philosophy to model a finished synthesis of the typical legislations of estate, agreement, tort, and crime. At a time whilst there's a powerful tendency between students to view the universal legislations as basically fragmentary, inconsistent, and contradictory, Brudner indicates as an alternative a coherence that synthesizes numerous interrelated dichotomies: reliable- established and right-based criminal paradigms, instrumental and non- instrumental conceptions of legislations, externalist and internalist interpretations of the universal legislation approach, and communitarian and individualist makes an attempt to stumbled on the felony company. Brudner covers certainly new flooring via an interpretation of the universal legislation from the point of view of Hegelian criminal philosophy. His unifying idea of universal legislation corresponds to Hegel's inspiration of Geist, suggesting a designation of the mutual dependence of the neighborhood and the atomistic self for his or her affirmation as ends.

Show description

Read or Download The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian Jurisprudence PDF

Similar jurisprudence books

Alan Brudner's The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian PDF

Countering the influential view of severe criminal reports that legislation is an incoherent mix of conflicting political ideologies, this e-book forges a new paradigm for knowing the typical legislations as being unified and systematic. Alan Brudner applies Hegel's felony and ethical philosophy to style a complete synthesis of the typical legislations of estate, agreement, tort, and crime.

Additional info for The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian Jurisprudence

Sample text

Once again, the common law merely recognizes and fulfills a preexisting relation. ŁŁŚ That use is in itself a property explains the basic elements of nuisance law. As part of an objectively valid mastery of things, use is inwardly circumscribed by a rule rendering it compatible with the equal user rights of other persons. One has a property objectively binding the world (rather than a privilege arrogated to oneself against it) only in uses capable of being recognized without self-effacement by others.

The common law's aversion to restraints on alienating land and chattels is surpassed only by its reverse hostility to the relinquishment or sale of other sorts of entities, for example, one's liberty, one's capacity to own property, or one's life. ī Those who view rules against restraints on alienation as serving efficient resource allocation have difficulty fitting within a single theory rules barring the alienation of life or libertyĺalthough they have tried. For Guido Calabresi and A. Īē While this may be an economist's reason for a rule against selling oneself into slavery, one may doubt whether it is the law's reason.

That first possession is not a full or self-sufficient ground of title is attested to by the common law itself. Suppose A takes possession of an ownerless tract of land by enclosing it with a fence on which he posts signs warning off trespassers. While A takes an extended holiday, B enters the land and puts it to intensive use for ten years. If A takes no action to oust B, his title will be extinguished in favor of B's. What is the ground of B's title? Against everyone but A his title can be called a possessory one, since no one but A has established even a minimal relationship to the land.

Download PDF sample

The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian Jurisprudence by Alan Brudner


by Kenneth
4.5

Rated 4.35 of 5 – based on 46 votes